After launching a nationwide search for our January 2014 Cover Guy, we were inundated with dudes with the confidence, looks and bodies you’d expect to see on the cover of the world’s best-selling men’s magazine. Literally thousands of guys posted their pics, uploaded their vitals and made us high-five each other for having readers who live the brand. In fact, we got such an incredible response to the Cover Guy Competition that we decided to not only celebrate the winner, Casey McDonald, but also finalist Mike van Wyk by giving each a cover. Get acquainted with both, and the other 18 finalists, by clicking through the gallery.